Paper Tiger Movie Review: Driver’s 1986 Crime Drama
This Paper Tiger movie review looks at James Gray’s gripping 1986 Queens crime drama, starring Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller. Paper Tiger is the best-reviewed film opening this weekend, and the quietest. James Gray’s 1986 Queens crime drama stars Adam Driver as a former cop whose family gets pulled into the Russian mafia, […]
This Paper Tiger movie review looks at James Gray’s gripping 1986 Queens crime drama, starring Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller.
Paper Tiger is the best-reviewed film opening this weekend, and the quietest. James Gray’s 1986 Queens crime drama stars Adam Driver as a former cop whose family gets pulled into the Russian mafia, and it is a slow, sad, beautifully made film about loyalty and the cost of the past. This review covers the story, the cast, what works, what does not, and our verdict.

Paper Tiger Movie Review: Quick Facts
- Release: November 13, 2026 (US theaters, limited); wide November 20, 2026
- Director: James Gray
- Runtime: 115 minutes
- Genre: Crime, drama
- Rating: R (language, some violence)
- Rotten Tomatoes: 85% (103 reviews, November 13, 2026)
- Metacritic: 79/100 (25 critics)
- Budget: About $15 million
- Festival: Cannes, May 16, 2026 (Main Competition)
- Where to watch: In limited US theaters from November 13, 2026. Wide release November 20. No streaming date yet.
Paper Tiger Movie Review: What Is Paper Tiger?
It is 1986 in Queens, New York. Gary Pearl, played by Adam Driver, is a former cop living a straight life with his wife Hester, played by Scarlett Johansson. Their son Irwin, played by Miles Teller, is an engineer, the family’s pride. Then Irwin gets involved with the Russian mafia, and the family is pulled back into a criminal world. The film is loosely based on Gray’s own family’s encounter with the Russian mafia in 1980s New York, and it shows.
The period detail, the neighborhood, and the fear all feel lived in. The crime is almost secondary. The film is really about a family, and what a father will do to protect it.
Paper Tiger Movie Review: Story, Spoiler-Light, Then Spoilers
Spoiler-light: the setup is simple and human. Gary Pearl has done his time in uniform and wants out of that world. Hester wants a normal life. Irwin, their son, is the good kid, the engineer, the one who made it. But Irwin’s work brings him into contact with the Russian mob, and a debt, a favor, a bad decision, pulls the whole family in.
The film’s first half is about watching a decent family slide toward trouble, one small compromise at a time. Gray directs it slowly and carefully, and the tension comes not from gunfights but from the knowledge that every choice is closing a door. The Queens of 1986 is rendered in full: the streets, the accents, the kitchens, the fear.
Spoilers ahead: the film’s turn comes when Gary realizes the family cannot buy or talk its way out, and he has to go back to the man he used to be. The reviews agree this is where the film is strongest: Driver’s Gary, quiet and careful for an hour, finally acts, and the shift is frightening. The mob boss, played by Victor Ptak, is not a cartoon villain but a businessman, which makes him worse.
We will not give away the final scenes here, because the film only opened in limited release today, and most viewers will see it when it goes wide on November 20. What we can say is that the film earns its ending, and that the last act is the reason critics are calling it Gray’s best work in years.
Paper Tiger Cast and Performances
| Actor | Character |
|---|---|
| Adam Driver | Gary Pearl |
| Scarlett Johansson | Hester Pearl |
| Miles Teller | Irwin Pearl |
| Victor Ptak | Mob boss |
Driver is superb. He plays Gary as a man holding himself together by force of will, all restraint until it is not. Johansson is his equal, playing Hester as a woman who knows what is happening and refuses to look away. Teller is the surprise: his Irwin is not a fool, but a good man who makes one bad choice, and Teller plays the shame and fear honestly. The supporting cast is strong, with Ptak’s mob boss standing out for how ordinary he seems, and Goudey and Engel grounding the family. Every performance serves the same story.
What Works
The performances work, first and always. Driver, Johansson, and Teller form a family that feels real, and the best scenes are the quiet ones between them. The period detail works: 1986 Queens feels like a memory rather than a set. Gray’s direction works. He trusts the audience, lets scenes breathe, and builds tension from character, not action. The family story works too. This is a crime film about what crime costs a family, and that separates it from every other mafia movie. The critics noticed: 85% on Rotten Tomatoes, and 79 on Metacritic.
What Does Not Work
The pace does not work for everyone. This is a slow film, and viewers who want a thriller will find the first hour quiet. The plot is familiar, and Gray does not reinvent it, he only tells it better than most. Some critics found it old-fashioned, and it is: classical, patient, occasionally too polite about its own violence. The limited release is a problem: most viewers cannot see it until November 20, and word of mouth must survive a week of waiting.
Paper Tiger Movie Review: Our Verdict
Paper Tiger earns a 4 out of 5. It is a gripping, beautifully made crime drama with three superb leads and a family story that hits hard, but a slow one, with a familiar plot that will test impatient viewers. See it when it goes wide on November 20, for Driver at his best. For more of his work, our best Adam Driver movies list is the place to start.
Where to Watch Paper Tiger
Paper Tiger is in limited US theaters from November 13, 2026, from Neon, and it goes wide on November 20. No streaming date has been announced yet. Our weekend guide for November 13 to 15 has the full list of what is new, and our Paper Tiger post has the full background. This Paper Tiger movie review will be updated when a streaming date is announced.
Paper Tiger Movie Review FAQ
Is Paper Tiger based on a true story?
Loosely. It is based on James Gray’s family’s encounter with the Russian mafia in 1980s New York.
Is Paper Tiger in wide release?
Not yet. It opens limited on November 13, 2026, and goes wide on November 20.
Who plays Gary Pearl in Paper Tiger?
Adam Driver plays Gary Pearl, a former cop, with Scarlett Johansson as Hester and Miles Teller as Irwin.
How long is Paper Tiger, and what is it rated?
It runs 115 minutes and is rated R for language and some violence.
Is Paper Tiger streaming?
Not yet. It is in theaters only.
Updated: November 13, 2026
Keep exploring
Every title in this guide has a page with its trailer, cast and legal streaming options.