Best Finn Wittrock Movies: 10 Roles, From La La Land to Hershey
Finn Wittrock has spent a decade being the most interesting person in every cast he joins. He trained at Juilliard, broke out as a murderous rich kid on American Horror Story, and went on to work with the biggest directors in Hollywood. Now he takes on his biggest role yet: Milton Hershey, the chocolate pioneer, […]
Finn Wittrock has spent a decade being the most interesting person in every cast he joins. He trained at Juilliard, broke out as a murderous rich kid on American Horror Story, and went on to work with the biggest directors in Hollywood. Now he takes on his biggest role yet: Milton Hershey, the chocolate pioneer, in Hershey, opening in theatres on November 25, 2026. This list of the best Finn Wittrock movies and shows ranks his ten strongest screen roles so far.

10. The Normal Heart (2014) — Albert
Wittrock’s first collaboration with Ryan Murphy was HBO’s The Normal Heart, the film of Larry Kramer’s play about the early AIDS crisis in New York. He plays Albert, a young man in the orbit of Mark Ruffalo’s Ned Weeks, in a cast packed with heavyweights. It is a small part, but it put him on Murphy’s radar — and that relationship would shape the next decade of his career. Where to watch: streams on Max.
9. Don’t Move (2024) — Richard
In Netflix’s lean survival thriller Don’t Move, Wittrock plays Richard, a seemingly kind stranger who helps a grieving woman in the woods — and then injects her with a paralysing drug, giving her twenty minutes before her body shuts down. Richard is calm, polite and utterly terrifying, and Wittrock plays him with the same smiling menace he brought to American Horror Story. Where to watch: streams on Netflix.
8. Deep Water (2022) — Tony Cameron
Adrian Lyne’s erotic thriller stars Ben Affleck and Ana de Armas as a married couple playing dangerous games with her lovers, and Wittrock plays Tony Cameron, an old college boyfriend who reconnects with Melinda on Facebook. Tony is charming, outdoorsy and completely unaware that Vic is watching his every move. What happens to Tony on the drive home is the moment the film turns dark. Where to watch: streams on Hulu.
7. Ratched (2020) — Edmund Tolleson
In Ryan Murphy’s One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest prequel, Wittrock plays Edmund Tolleson, a charismatic killer locked in a mental hospital and the dark mirror of Sarah Paulson’s Nurse Ratched. Edmund is handsome, funny and genuinely frightening, and Wittrock plays him as a man who knows exactly what he is. Their scenes together crackle, and the role proved he could carry a major series as a leading man. Where to watch: streams on Netflix.
6. American Crime Story (2018) — Jeffrey Trail
Wittrock earned his second Emmy nomination as Jeffrey Trail, the murder victim at the centre of The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story. Trail is a warm, decent man whose friendship with Andrew Cunanan turns fatal, and Wittrock plays him with a heartbreaking openness. His later flashback scenes are among the show’s most wrenching. Where to watch: streams on Netflix.
Halfway through the best Finn Wittrock movies and shows, a pattern is hard to miss: he keeps playing charming men with something dark underneath, and he never lets you look away.
5. Judy (2019) — Mickey Deans
In the Judy Garland biopic, Wittrock plays Mickey Deans, Garland’s fifth and final husband — a nightclub manager who marries her late in her life and tries, in his own flawed way, to look after her. Opposite Renée Zellweger, who won the Oscar for the role, Wittrock is tender and complicated: a man who loves Garland and also needs her fame. It is one of the best Finn Wittrock movies for showing his softer side. Where to watch: rent or buy on Prime Video and Apple TV.
4. Unbroken (2014) — Francis “Mac” McNamara
Angelina Jolie’s war drama gave Wittrock one of his first big film roles: Francis “Mac” McNamara, the bombardier who survives a plane crash with Louis Zamperini and then survives 47 days adrift on a raft. Mac is the film’s moral test — a man whose faith breaks under starvation and fear — and Wittrock plays his collapse with painful honesty. Where to watch: rent or buy on Prime Video and Apple TV.
3. La La Land (2016) — Greg Earnest
Wittrock’s part in La La Land is small — he plays Greg, Mia’s boyfriend at the start of the film, the one who takes her to a party and leaves her stranded there. But it matters: Greg is the push Mia needs to walk into the party where she meets Sebastian, and the scene sets up everything that follows. Wittrock plays him as casually careless, the kind of boyfriend who never notices what he has. Where to watch: rent or buy on Prime Video and Apple TV.
2. The Big Short (2015) — Jamie Shipley
Ask fans to name the best Finn Wittrock movies and this one comes up first for many of them. In Adam McKay’s Oscar-winning drama about the 2008 financial crash, Wittrock plays Jamie Shipley, a young investor who spots the housing bubble with his partner Charlie Geller and bets everything against it. Jamie is funny, furious and out of his depth, and Wittrock holds his own against Christian Bale, Steve Carell and Ryan Gosling in an ensemble packed with stars. Where to watch: rent or buy on Prime Video and Apple TV.
1. American Horror Story (2014–16) — Dandy Mott
Wittrock’s defining role is Dandy Mott, the spoiled, murderous rich kid at the centre of American Horror Story: Freak Show. Dandy is charming, childish and utterly remorseless — a killer who treats murder like a tantrum — and Wittrock plays him with a grin that never leaves his face. The performance earned him an Emmy nomination and made him a star overnight. He returned as Tristan Duffy in Hotel and Jether Polk in Roanoke. Where to watch: streams on Hulu.
Planning a movie night? Check showtimes at Fandango for the latest releases playing near you, including the big-screen titles on this list.
FAQ
Is Finn Wittrock in Hershey?
Yes — he plays Milton Hershey himself in Hershey, the biographical drama about the founder of the Hershey chocolate company, opening in theatres on November 25, 2026. Alexandra Daddario co-stars as his wife Kitty. See our guide to the movies coming out November 25, 2026 for the full Thanksgiving week lineup.
Where can I watch the best Finn Wittrock movies?
Ratched, American Crime Story and Don’t Move stream on Netflix, while American Horror Story and Deep Water are on Hulu. The Normal Heart is on Max, and La La Land, The Big Short, Unbroken and Judy are widely available to rent or buy.
What is Finn Wittrock’s next project after Hershey?
He was cast as Guy Gardner for the Green Lantern series, and he has more film work lined up after Hershey. We will keep this list updated as his career grows.
That is our pick of the best Finn Wittrock movies and shows, from a party guest in La La Land to a chocolate empire in Hershey. If you only watch three, make them American Horror Story, The Big Short and Judy — together they show everything he can do.
Keep exploring
Every title in this guide has a page with its trailer, cast and legal streaming options.