Black Phone 2 Review
This Black Phone 2 review covers the story, performances, scares, and verdict for Scott Derrickson’s sequel, and you can find more in our Movie Reviews section. The first Black Phone worked because it stayed small. A boy trapped in a basement, a disconnected phone, and the voices of kids who did not make it out. […]
This Black Phone 2 review covers the story, performances, scares, and verdict for Scott Derrickson’s sequel, and you can find more in our Movie Reviews section.
The first Black Phone worked because it stayed small. A boy trapped in a basement, a disconnected phone, and the voices of kids who did not make it out. It was a horror film about listening carefully and holding your nerve. Black Phone 2 keeps the phone, keeps the dread, and moves the story somewhere colder and stranger. It is not just a repeat of the first film. It is bigger, bloodier, and more openly supernatural, and that change will decide how much you like it.

Directed by Scott Derrickson, who co-wrote the film with C. Robert Cargill, the sequel picks up four years after the original and is set in 1982. Finney Blake, played again by Mason Thames, is now 17 and still carrying what happened to him. He survived the Grabber, but survival did not leave him settled. His younger sister Gwen, played by Madeleine McGraw, is 15 and starting to hear the black phone in her dreams. Her visions point to Alpine Lake, a winter camp where three boys were hunted. Gwen pushes for answers, Finney goes with her to protect her, and a blizzard closes in around them. The camp starts to feel less like a place and more like a trap.
Black Phone 2 Review: What the Sequel Is About
Ethan Hawke returns as the Grabber, and this time he is not simply a man in a basement. Death has not finished him. He reaches back from the other side, angry and fixed on revenge, with Gwen in his sights. That shift is the film’s boldest choice. The first movie asked what a trapped kid could do with a phone that should not work. This one asks what happens when the killer refuses to stay dead and the phone starts ringing in sleep.
The winter setting does much of the work. Snow, ice, and empty cabins make every walk outside feel exposed, and Derrickson uses silence well. A ringing phone in a quiet room still lands.
The Performances Carry the Film
Mason Thames is better here than he was in the first film, and that matters because Finney could easily have become a symbol of trauma rather than a person. Thames plays him as guarded, tired, and still stubborn. He flinches at the right moments and does not turn into a stock action hero. When he stands up for Gwen, it feels like a choice he has to force himself to make.
Madeleine McGraw is the film’s center, though. Gwen is funny, blunt, and brave in a way that never feels written to be cute. McGraw handles the dream material without overplaying it. She looks scared when she should, and determined when the story needs her to lead. A lot of sequels push the younger sibling aside. This one hands her the phone, in a sense, and trusts her with it.
Ethan Hawke remains the reason the Grabber works. He does not need a long speech to be frightening. A change in tone, a pause, a grin that arrives too late — that is enough.
What Works
The atmosphere is the strongest part of the film. The move to Alpine Lake opens up the visuals without losing the claustrophobia of the original. Snow narrows the world. Cabins, frozen paths, and dark water do the same job the basement once did: they limit where you can run. The sibling relationship is the second strength. Finney and Gwen argue, protect each other, and misunderstand each other in ways that feel true to a brother and sister who have been through something terrible. The horror lands harder because you care who gets hurt.
The scares are also more varied this time. There are sudden shocks, yes, but the better moments are slow. A phone ringing where no phone should be. A figure standing too still in the snow. A dream that starts normally and then bends. Derrickson understands that waiting is often scarier than showing, and the film is at its best when it trusts that instinct.
What Does Not Work
The mythology gets murky. The film sketches how the phone works now, what the Grabber has become, and why Alpine Lake matters, but it does not fill in enough of those details. Some viewers will enjoy filling the gaps themselves. Others will leave with fair questions about the rules. When a sequel expands its world, it needs to be a little more careful about its own logic, and this one sometimes waves a hand where a clearer answer would help.
The middle section also sags. Once the camp mystery is set up, the film circles it for a while before tightening again, and a few dream passages repeat the same beat: dread, a glimpse, a wake-up. The extra gore will split the audience too. The first film was frightening without leaning on graphic violence. This one is rated R for strong violent content, gore, teen drug use, and language, and it earns that rating. If you liked the first film mainly for its restraint, be ready for a rougher sequel.
Our Verdict
Our Black Phone 2 review verdict is 3.5 out of 5 stars. Black Phone 2 is a worthy sequel that earns its scares and deepens its two leads, even if its mythology is thinner than its mood. It is colder, louder, and less tidy than the original, and that trade will work for horror fans who want a sequel to take a swing rather than play safe.
Critics were broadly positive, around 72 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, with a strong audience response in the mid-80s. See the film’s details on TMDB.
Trailer, Runtime, and Where to Watch
The trailer gives a fair sense of the winter-camp setting and the Grabber’s return without spoiling the best turns.
As noted in this Black Phone 2 review, Black Phone 2 was released in theaters in the United States on October 17, 2025, by Universal Pictures, after premiering at Fantastic Fest. It later reached Peacock, starting January 16, 2026, and it is also available through digital rental and purchase outlets. Check your usual service for current availability before settling in, since streaming lineups change.
Who Should Watch It
Watch it if you liked the first Black Phone, if you enjoy winter horror, or if you want a sequel that actually moves its characters forward instead of resetting them. Skip it, or save it for daylight, if graphic horror, dream logic, and stories about harm to teenagers are hard for you. This is not a light Halloween watch. It is a film about trauma wearing a horror costume, and it takes both parts seriously.
This Black Phone 2 review finds Black Phone 2 does not match the first film’s tight tension in every scene, but it understands Finney and Gwen, and it leaves you with a phone ringing in the cold.
For horror fans weighing a watch, this Black Phone 2 review’s bottom line is simple: expect a colder, scarier sequel that is worth seeing, even with its murkier mythology.
Keep exploring
Every title in this guide has a page with its trailer, cast and legal streaming options.